Customer effort score asks one question after a service contact: how hard was that? It is the youngest of the three common feedback scores. It came from a study of more than 75,000 customers. The authors argued that cutting effort builds loyalty, and that exceeding expectations does not (HBR).
What is customer effort score?
Customer effort score, or CES, measures how much work a customer did to get a request done. The Corporate Executive Board, or CEB, introduced it in 2010. The article ran in Harvard Business Review. It was by Matthew Dixon, Karen Freeman and Nick Toman (HBR).
The original question was “How much effort did you personally have to put forth to handle your request?” Customers answered from 1, very low effort, to 5, very high effort. So a lower score was better (HBR).
Their case rested on a gap. Of the 100 service heads surveyed, 89 said their main strategy was to exceed expectations. Yet 84% of customers said their latest contact had not exceeded expectations (HBR). The team argued that firms should cut effort instead.
Dixon and Toman wrote a book on the idea in 2013, with Rick DeLisi (Penguin). Gartner closed its deal for CEB on April 5, 2017 (Gartner 8-K).
How do you calculate customer effort score?
Add every rating and divide by the number of responses. That gives an average. Contentsquare notes that on an agree scale, a higher average means lower effort (Contentsquare). Some teams report the share of top-two answers instead, such as 6 or 7 on a 7-point scale (Decagon).
Check the direction before you compare anything. The original CEB scale put 1 at very low effort, so lower was better (HBR). Many vendor surveys now use an agree statement, such as “The company made it easy for me to handle my issue,” where higher is better. Vendors credit CEB with that later wording (Contentsquare). The US federal standard offers a similar ease statement: “It was easy to complete what I needed to do” (OMB Circular A-11).
| Version | Wording | Scale | Better when |
|---|---|---|---|
| CEB original, 2010 | How much effort did you personally have to put forth to handle your request? | 1 (very low effort) to 5 (very high effort) | The score is lower |
| Agree statement in vendor surveys | The company made it easy for me to handle my issue. | 1 to 5 or 1 to 7, strongly disagree to strongly agree | The score is higher |
| Federal driver statement | It was easy to complete what I needed to do. | Five-point agree scale | The score is higher |
For illustration, a program sends the agree statement on a 7-point scale after 200 redemption calls. A total of 50 members answer 7, 60 answer 6, 40 answer 5 and 25 answer 4. Another 12 answer 3, 8 answer 2 and 5 answer 1. The ratings sum to 1,067, so the average is 5.34. The top-two share is 110 of 200, or 55%.
Does customer effort score predict loyalty?
CEB’s own data said yes. Of customers who reported low effort, 94% intended to buy again and 88% intended to spend more. Only 1% planned to speak ill of the firm. Of customers who had a hard time, 81% planned to spread bad word of mouth (HBR). CEB defined loyalty as intent, and the figures come from its own survey.
Later work found less. Researchers compared metrics for 93 firms in 18 industries. Effort score alone had little to no predictive power for retention, and it ranked last. Combining it with satisfaction metrics improved the forecasts (de Haan et al., 2015). Only 20.5% of the sample had an effort score, because the rest had made no request.
A large field study adds a limit. It covered 314,194 interactions with 96 brands. In general, more effort meant less satisfaction. In some cases it meant more. The channel and the sector changed the result (Ardelet and Benavent, 2022).
How do you reduce customer effort?
The HBR authors name five tactics. Cut repeat calls by dealing with related downstream issues. Arm reps to handle the emotional side of a contact. Minimize the need to switch channels. Gather and use feedback from customers who struggled. Focus on problem solving, not speed (HBR).
Their data backs the first two. Of repeat calls, 22% involved downstream issues tied to the original problem, even when that problem was fixed. Another 24% came from emotional disconnects, such as a customer who did not trust the rep’s answer (HBR).
Extra generosity did little. A refund, a free product or free shipping made customers only marginally more loyal than meeting their needs (HBR). Small changes in wording worked too. Osram Sylvania cut its score from 2.8 to 2.2 that way (HBR).
A program can apply this to the claim flow. Answer the next question a member will ask in the same reply, such as where the points went and when they will post. Train reps on the tone of a bad-news reply as well as the facts.
How does customer effort score differ from CSAT and NPS?
CES rates a task, CSAT rates an experience and NPS rates a relationship. CEB credited the strength of CES in service to two traits. It captures impressions at the transaction level, and it captures negative experiences as well as positive ones (HBR). Read it with the other two. Our entries on Net Promoter Score and the measuring customer loyalty guide show how the set fits together.
How do loyalty programs use customer effort score?
A loyalty program has many moments that cost a member work. Members look for a balance, claim missing points, redeem and ask questions. J.D. Power finds that the basics drive satisfaction. Roughly half of airline members do not understand how to earn or redeem. Satisfaction climbs 123 points when they understand redemption (J.D. Power, 2018). It runs 99 points higher among members with no problems (J.D. Power, 2017).
Programs also sell lower effort as a perk. Delta says every SkyMiles Medallion member gets priority when calling. The priority rises with each tier, up to a VIP line at Diamond (Delta).
Ask after a defined contact or task, such as a points claim, a redemption or a status request. Keep the survey to one question. Then read the score beside repeat contacts. Only members who made a request can answer, so silent members drop out. A claim that took three contacts is high effort, whatever the member scores it.
Report effort by journey. A balance check, a claim and a redemption cost a member different amounts of work, so one blended score hides the worst of them. Track the share of members who needed a second contact next to the score. Then fix the journey with the highest effort first.
How GRAVTY handles customer effort score
GRAVTY AI-Scan lets a shopper upload a receipt from any merchant. It parses the receipt, maps every line to a SKU and credits the earn or triggers offers in milliseconds (retail loyalty). A receipt that earns on upload leaves no missing-points claim to file.
Patented Visual Rules let business teams change program logic without an IT ticket (GRAVTY technology). A source of effort can then be fixed in days.
Frequently asked questions
Who created the customer effort score?
Matthew Dixon, Karen Freeman and Nick Toman created it. They worked at CEB, the Corporate Executive Board. They introduced it in 2010 in a paper for Harvard Business Review (HBR). The study had more than 75,000 customers.
What is a good customer effort score?
A good score is one that holds steady or improves on your own scale, because scales differ across surveys. On the original 1 to 5 scale, lower was better. Osram Sylvania cut its score from 2.8 to 2.2, which CEB put 18.5% below the average it saw for B2B firms (HBR).
Does a lower customer effort score mean better service?
It does on the original scale, where 1 meant very low effort (HBR). It does not on agree scales, where a higher score means the task was easier (Contentsquare). Check which scale a report uses before you read a trend.
When should you send a customer effort survey?
Send it right after a defined contact or task, such as a closed claim or a redemption. CEB credited CES with capturing impressions at the transaction level, where NPS captures a broader view of the firm (HBR). A survey sent weeks later asks members to recall the work.
Is customer effort score the same as customer engagement score?
No, they share the CES short form but measure different things. Customer effort score is a survey on how hard a request was. Customer engagement score adds up what customers do, with a weight on each action. Our member engagement entry covers the second kind in a loyalty program.
