Consent management is how a business asks for permission to use personal data, records the answer, obeys it and lets the person change it. A loyalty program asks at sign-up, in the app and at the till. Each answer has to be stored and obeyed in every system that sends a message or shares data.

Consent management covers four jobs. Software that does the first three is called a consent management platform. It shows the banner or preference center, stores each choice with a timestamp, and passes the choice to the tools that act on it.

  • Ask. Show the choice in plain words, with each purpose apart from the rest.
  • Record. Keep who agreed, when, what they saw and how (ICO).
  • Honor. Stop the sends and tags the moment a person says no.
  • Renew. Review each consent and refresh it when purposes change (ICO).

The law sets what counts as consent. GDPR says it must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous (GDPR Article 4(11)). It comes from a statement or a clear action. Silence, pre-ticked boxes and inactivity do not count (Recital 32). The business must be able to prove consent was given (GDPR Article 7(1)).

GDPR lists six lawful bases for using data. Consent is one. A contract and legitimate interests are two others (GDPR Article 6). A program often rests the membership on a contract and its marketing on consent.

GDPR and California start from different places. GDPR needs a lawful basis before use begins. California lets a business collect data first. The consumer then has a right to tell it not to sell or share that data (CCPA § 1798.120(a)). A consumer under 16 is the exception. For that group the business needs affirmative authorization first (CCPA § 1798.120(c)).

TestGDPRCalifornia
DefinitionFreely given, specific, informed, unambiguous (Art. 4(11))Same four words, tied to a narrow purpose (§ 1798.140(h))
BundlingSeparate from other matters (Art. 7(2))Broad terms of use do not count as consent
WithdrawalAs easy as giving it (Art. 7(3))Revocable at any time for incentive programs (§ 1798.125(b)(3))
Choice designNot conditional on unneeded data (Art. 7(4))Symmetry in choice (11 CCR § 7004)

The ICO gives a store example. A shop that makes shoppers agree to share their details with other stores at checkout has made consent a condition of sale. That sharing is not needed for the sale, so the consent is not freely given (ICO). A program that asks for partner-sharing consent before it awards points faces the same test.

The UK regulator says consent should be unbundled from other terms. It should offer separate options for different kinds of processing (ICO). It adds that consent should not be a condition of service unless the data is needed for that service.

California goes further on design. A banner with “Accept All” and “More Information” is not symmetrical, because accepting takes one step and refusing takes more. “Accept All” and “Decline All” is an equal choice (11 CCR § 7004). The statute says agreement obtained through dark patterns is not consent (CCPA § 1798.140(h)).

Regulators test whether the banner works as shown. In September 2025 the CNIL fined SHEIN 150 million euros. It found that advertising cookies were placed as soon as a visitor arrived, before any click on the banner. It also found that new cookies were still placed after a visitor clicked “Refuse all” (CNIL).

Browsers can send choices too. One example is the Global Privacy Control signal. It tells a business a person’s privacy choices. Brave and Firefox support it (GPC).

California treats a signal like this as an opt-out. A business that sells or shares data must honor it (11 CCR § 7025).

The state has acted on this. In 2022 Sephora agreed to pay $1.2 million. The state said Sephora ignored opt-out requests sent by privacy controls that users had switched on (California AG).

California writes a rule for loyalty programs. The statute allows loyalty, rewards and club card programs (CCPA § 1798.125(a)(3)). A business can enter a consumer into a financial incentive program only with prior opt-in consent. The consent must state the material terms, and the consumer can revoke it at any time. After a refusal, the business must wait at least 12 months before it asks again (CCPA § 1798.125(b)(3)).

Starbucks shows how a program says this. Members opt in by signing up, and joining is voluntary. They can turn off promotional emails at any time. Starbucks can still send notes about orders and accounts (Starbucks Privacy Notice).

Email has its own clock. The FTC says a business must honor an opt-out request within 10 business days (FTC CAN-SPAM guide). Push, text and partner sharing each need a separate record, because a member can accept one and refuse the others.

Text messages carry their own US rule. Marketing texts sent with an automatic dialer need prior express written consent (47 CFR 64.1200(a)(2)). The signed agreement must say the person does not have to sign it as a condition of buying anything (47 CFR 64.1200(f)(9)).

What should a loyalty program do about withdrawal and records?

Withdrawal is the test of a good setup. A member who joined a channel in one tap should be able to leave it in one tap. A preference center that reads the same list of purposes as the join form keeps the two in step.

Two numbers keep a program honest: the opt-in rate for each channel at sign-up, and the share of members whose consent records are complete. A drop in the first points to a clumsy ask. A drop in the second points to a gap in the audit trail.

Loyalty teams own the reasons a member returns, so they own the renewal of consent as much as privacy counsel does. Our post on first-party data strategy makes that case.

The ICO lists what a consent record must show (ICO consent records):

  • Who agreed, by name or ID.
  • When, with a dated copy or a timestamp.
  • What they were told, including the version of the form and the privacy notice.
  • How they agreed, and the data they sent.
  • Whether they have withdrawn, and when.

For illustration, a program with 2 million members tracks four consents per member: email, push, partner sharing and location. That is 8 million live consent records. A withdrawal adds a new record and leaves the old one in place. The history then shows what was agreed on any given day.

Loyalty Juggernaut describes a governed audience layer in its retail solution. Brands buy access to retailer audiences. They never touch raw personal data. The page calls the layer shared, governed and opt-in. It adds consent-graph-aware activation. Spin Premia by FEMSA uses it with 20 CPGs.

The financial services page lists GDPR compliance for the platform.

Frequently asked questions

What is a consent management platform?

A consent management platform is software that shows consent choices and stores the answers. It also passes them to other tools. A business needs one because it must be able to show consent (GDPR Article 7(1)).

Is consent the only legal basis under GDPR?

No. GDPR lists six lawful bases, and consent is one. The rest are contract, legal duty, vital interests, public task and legitimate interests (GDPR Article 6).

How long does consent last?

The UK GDPR sets no fixed time limit, and consent is likely to fade over time. The ICO says to keep consents under review and to get fresh consent when purposes change (ICO).

Does withdrawing consent undo earlier processing?

No. Withdrawal does not affect the lawfulness of processing done before it. Processing based on consent stops once the person withdraws (GDPR Article 7(3)).

How fast must a marketing email opt-out be honored?

Within 10 business days under the US CAN-SPAM Act. The opt-out mechanism must also keep working for at least 30 days after the message is sent (FTC).