Breakage also means goods broken in transit (Dictionary.com). In accounting, it means rights a customer paid for and never used. ASC 606 says so: “Those unexercised rights are often referred to as breakage” (ASC 606-10-55-47). In a loyalty program, it sets how much of the points liability turns into revenue with no reward ever handed over.

What is breakage in a loyalty program?

Loyalty breakage is the share of issued points that members never redeem. Some points expire under the program’s rules. Others sit in accounts members have forgotten, or in balances below the cheapest reward.

Finance works with expected breakage. It is an estimate set when points are issued and revised as members act. Actual breakage is known only much later. The gap between the two shows up as catch-up adjustments to revenue.

How is breakage estimated?

Breakage is estimated from redemption history, and the clearest view is a cohort curve. Finance groups points by the month they were issued. It then tracks the share redeemed as each group ages. Older groups flatten out, and the level where they flatten sets the expected redemption rate. Breakage is what is left.

Filers say the same in their own words. Air Miles in Canada used “vintage analysis” to set its rate (Alliance Data 2016 10-K). Delta builds models on past redemption patterns (Delta 2025 10-K). American Express models what its current members will redeem. Its inputs include redemption trends and how long each member has been enrolled (American Express 2025 10-K).

For illustration, a store issues 10 million points in January. Each is worth one cent off. Its older batches of points level off at 75% redeemed. So finance expects 7.5 million to be redeemed and 2.5 million to break. The points carry $75,000 of deferred revenue.

  1. Month 12. Members have redeemed 6.2 million points. Revenue to date is 6.2 ÷ 7.5 of the $75,000, or $62,000.
  2. Curve flattens early. The cohort levels off at 70%. Finance cuts expected redemptions to 7 million, so revenue to date becomes $66,429. That adds $4,429 of revenue in one period.
  3. Curve keeps rising. At 80%, revenue to date falls to $58,125. That is a $3,875 reversal.

A five-point move in the estimate shifted 5% to 6% of the cohort’s deferred revenue. In a program holding $500 million of deferred revenue, the same move is worth about $26 million to $30 million.

How does breakage become revenue under ASC 606 and IFRS 15?

ASC 606 sets two paths. The choice turns on whether the business expects to be entitled to breakage. If it does, it books breakage “in proportion to the pattern of rights exercised by the customer” (ASC 606-10-55-48). If it does not, it waits until the chance of redemption is remote. IFRS 15 sets the same rule in paragraph B46 (IFRS Foundation).

The expectation has to clear a cap. A business counts on breakage only to the extent that a large reversal of booked revenue is unlikely (ASC 606-10-55-48 and 32-11). Booking breakage at the sale is off the table. The boards “rejected an approach” that would have done so (Deloitte DART 8.8). Breakage changes when revenue lands, and the total stays the same.

Unclaimed property laws come first. If a state can claim the unused balance, the money stays a liability. It never becomes revenue (ASC 606-10-55-49).

QuestionProportional approachRemote approach
When it appliesThe business expects to be entitled to breakageThe business does not expect to be entitled to breakage
When breakage becomes revenueAlongside each redemptionOnce redemption becomes remote
Gift card case$1,000 sold, $200 expected breakage: each $40 redeemed brings $10 more$1,000 sold, $800 redeemed: the last $200 is booked once redemption is remote
Points caseA portfolio of similar points, booked as redemptions come inA single customer’s option, or a balance left once redemptions stop
Balances owed to a stateStay a liabilityStay a liability

Deloitte’s DART guide works both gift card cases (DART 8.8). For points, it applies the proportional path to a portfolio of similar rights. It applies the remote path to a single customer’s option (DART 11.10). The full five-step model is under ASC 606.

What is gift card breakage?

Gift card breakage follows the same rule with one difference. The customer paid cash for the whole card, so the full balance is deferred and breakage comes back as extra revenue. Points are carved out of a sale, so expected breakage already shrinks the amount deferred.

Starbucks cards do not expire in the US, and Starbucks books expected breakage in step with card redemptions. In fiscal 2025 breakage came to $200.4 million in company-operated stores. Licensed stores added $22.0 million (Starbucks fiscal 2025 10-K). Ulta Beauty booked $27.0 million of gift card breakage in fiscal 2025. It books it only where unclaimed property laws do not claim the balance (Ulta Beauty fiscal 2025 10-K).

What moves breakage?

Expiry rules move it, and Air Miles shows how far. In 2011, Air Miles set a five-year expiry on all miles, with the first date at the end of 2016. Redemptions rose 60% in 2016 as members raced the deadline. On December 1, 2016, the program dropped the policy (Alliance Data 2016 10-K).

The breakage estimate fell from 26% to 20%. The liability rose $284.5 million, with the same amount taken out of revenue. The company tied $241.7 million of that to the end of the expiry policy (Alliance Data 2016 10-K).

Reward design moves it too. A balance below the cheapest reward cannot be spent. Raise the first threshold and more points get stuck. Small changes in the estimate carry large sums. At American Express, a 0.25-point rise in its ultimate redemption rate would add about $229 million to its rewards liability (American Express 2025 10-K).

Is high breakage good or bad for a loyalty program?

High breakage lifts reported results. A point that is never redeemed is revenue with no reward to deliver. In the illustration, five points of breakage moved 5% to 6% of the cohort’s deferred revenue.

It also counts the members a program has lost, and the loss is uneven. In card rewards, since the end of 2021, the share of subprime cardholders who forfeit rewards has climbed to more than double the overall rate (CFPB). Breakage built on lapse is fragile, too. When Air Miles members rushed to redeem, the change in estimate came out of a single year’s revenue.

Read breakage by segment. A rising estimate among members who used to redeem is an early churn signal. Loyalty program breakage covers the trade-offs in depth.

How GRAVTY handles breakage

A breakage model is only as good as the history behind it. GRAVTY records every earn, burn and expiry event at the member and transaction level. Finance can build cohort curves for each segment from real redemptions.

GRAVTY tracks the cost and value of every point issued and redeemed. That gives finance and loyalty teams the liability and breakage insight they need to govern the program. For airline programs, Loyalty Juggernaut lists scenario planning and what-if analysis (airline loyalty). Run an expiry or threshold change through it before the rule goes live.

Say breakage jumps in one segment. A team can ask GRAVTY Agentic AI Compass why the metric changed. Compass compares segments and drills into the odd spike in plain language (Agentic AI Compass).

Frequently asked questions

What is a normal breakage rate for loyalty points?

There is no standard rate. Each program sets its own from its own redemption history, and the published figures vary widely. Air Miles cut its estimate from 26% to 20% in 2016 (Alliance Data 2016 10-K). American Express puts its ultimate redemption rate at 96%, rounded down. That leaves breakage of 4% or less (American Express 2025 10-K).

Is breakage revenue?

Yes. Expected breakage becomes revenue as members redeem the rest of their points (ASC 606-10-55-48). If the business does not expect breakage, it waits until redemption is remote. Until then, the value sits in the contract liability.

Do points that never expire still have breakage?

Yes. Points that never expire still go unused when members leave or forget them. Delta tells members its miles do not expire (Delta). It still estimates mileage breakage with statistical models (Delta 2025 10-K).

Who owns the breakage estimate?

Finance owns the breakage estimate, and the loyalty team owns most of what moves it. Expiry rules and reward prices both change how many points get redeemed. Alliance Data named changes in program structure and in rewards offered as factors in its own estimate (Alliance Data 2016 10-K).

What else does breakage mean?

Outside accounting, breakage means things broken, or an allowance for goods broken in transit or in use (Dictionary.com). In horse racing, it is the money a track keeps when it pays winning bets only in multiples of dimes (Dictionary.com).