A member who trusts a program stops checking its math. The balance should be right, the reward should be there and the data should stay private. That expectation is brand trust. A loyalty program’s rules and records are where it is kept or broken.

What is brand trust?

Brand trust is the confidence customers place in a brand to do what it says. Trust research gives it three parts. In the 1995 model of Mayer, Davis and Schoorman, a trusted party is seen to have ability, benevolence and integrity. Ability is the skill to do the job. Benevolence is care for the customer’s welfare. Integrity is steady adherence to values the customer finds acceptable (Mayer). Trust itself is the “willingness to be vulnerable” to that party.

Marketers took the idea up for brands. In 1994, Morgan and Hunt found that successful relationship marketing needs commitment and trust (Morgan and Hunt). Delgado-Ballester and colleagues call trust the “cornerstone” of a relationship and the top attribute a brand can own. Their 2003 paper built a scale to measure it (Delgado-Ballester et al., 2003).

What builds brand trust?

Each part of trust asks something different of a brand. Mayer’s model adds one more input, the customer’s own tendency to trust. All four add to trust in a specific party independently (Mayer). A brand that is skilled but careless with data is working on one part only.

Part of trustWhat the customer asksWhat the brand doesWhere a loyalty program shows it
AbilityCan they do the job?Deliver what was promised, every timeBalances post on time, rewards are in stock, redemption works
BenevolenceDo they care how this goes for me?Act in the customer’s interestFair expiry rules, early notice of changes, data used as expected
IntegrityDo they keep their word?Publish the rules, then follow themA published award chart, terms that match practice

A single incident can cost a brand its standing. Aaker’s example is Volkswagen. After the EPA’s 2015 notice of violation, the public no longer saw the brand as trustworthy (Aaker).

Why does brand trust matter for revenue?

Chaudhuri and Holbrook studied 107 brands in 2001, drawing on three separate surveys of consumers and brand managers. They held product and brand traits fixed. Even so, brand trust and brand affect together set both purchase loyalty and attitudinal loyalty. Purchase loyalty led to more market share. Attitudinal loyalty led to a higher price for the brand (Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001).

Costco states the same chain in its annual report. Damage to its brands or reputation can hurt sales, diminish member trust and reduce renewal rates. Its renewal rate was 92.3% in the U.S. and Canada, and 89.8% worldwide, at the end of fiscal 2025 (Costco 10-K).

For illustration, a paid program has 100,000 members at a $60 fee. At 90% renewal, 90,000 members renew and fees come to $5.4 million. A broken promise cuts renewal to 85%. Now 85,000 renew and fees fall to $5.1 million. That is a $300,000 gap before any lost spend.

How do you measure brand trust?

There are two reads, and a program needs both. A survey scale asks members how far they rely on the brand. Delgado-Ballester’s team built a multidimensional scale and showed through psychometric tests that it is reliable and valid (Delgado-Ballester et al., 2003). Behavior shows what members do with that trust. Renewal rate is one such read, as Costco’s filing shows. Costco calls its rate a trailing calculation. It captures renewals in the period seven to eighteen months before the reporting date (Costco 10-K). Any program that reports renewal should state its window. Repeat purchase and redemption are other reads.

A trust score on its own tells a team little. Ask the same members the questions and track what they do next. Then split the results by tier, tenure and channel to see where trust is weakest. A random holdout shows whether a change in the program moved the score.

A trust survey for a program can follow the three parts. For ability, ask whether points post correctly and rewards arrive on time. For benevolence, ask whether the program has the member’s interests in mind. For integrity, ask whether it does what its terms say. Score each part on its own, because a weak part points to a different fix.

How do loyalty programs build and lose brand trust?

Data is the first test. Pew surveyed 5,101 U.S. adults in May 2023. Among those who had heard of AI, 81% said the information companies collect will be used in ways people are not comfortable with. Over half of all adults (56%) said they always, almost always or often click “agree” without reading a privacy policy (Pew Research Center, 2023). A program that asks for data from members like these has to earn the right to use it.

The law sets a floor. The GDPR says personal data shall be processed lawfully, fairly and in a transparent manner. It also says the data shall be limited to what is necessary for the purposes it serves (GDPR Article 5). Those lines read like a trust policy. A program that asks for less, and says why, gives members less to worry about.

The program’s rules are the next test. Marriott Bonvoy’s terms say an account inactive for 24 consecutive months forfeits all its points. They also say the program can amend its rules, with or without notice, even if the change affects the value of points (Marriott Bonvoy terms). Both clauses are common in program terms, and members agreed to them. They mark where a program can spend or save trust.

Hyatt took the other side in February 2026. It called its published award chart something members “value and trust.” It said it would keep fixed point thresholds for award nights (Hyatt, 2026). The choice cost the program flexibility. That cost is why members believe it. Our guide to brand loyalty covers the attachment that trust feeds, and the entry on points expiration covers the rule most members meet first.

A program can act on this within a quarter:

  1. Publish the rules that matter most, and say which ones will not change.
  2. Set a notice period for changes, even where the terms do not require one.
  3. List every data field the program holds, with the reason for each.
  4. Track how often members dispute a balance or fail to redeem, as well as renewal.

How GRAVTY handles brand trust

A member’s trust breaks where the platform is in charge: a wrong balance, a failed redemption, an account taken over. GRAVTY runs under a 99.99% uptime SLA. AI-Trust uses machine-learning models to flag unusual earn and redemption behavior as it happens, and scoring models can be set per program.

The Agentic AI Compass is the GRAVTY AI analyst. It keeps each recommendation explainable and auditable, so a team can trace why an offer or a change was proposed. For a deeper look at account takeover and promotion abuse, see our guide to loyalty fraud prevention.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between brand trust and brand loyalty?

Brand trust comes first, and brand loyalty is one result of it. In a study of 107 brands, brand trust and brand affect combined to determine purchase loyalty and attitudinal loyalty (Chaudhuri and Holbrook, 2001). Trust sits upstream of both kinds of loyalty.

What are the three parts of trust?

They are ability, benevolence and integrity. In Mayer, Davis and Schoorman’s model, a party is trusted when it is seen to have the skills for the job. It must also care about the other party’s welfare. And it must follow values the other finds acceptable (Mayer).

Can a brand lose trust quickly?

Yes. Volkswagen lost brand equity after the EPA issued a notice of violation in September 2015 over its emissions numbers. As the news spread, the public no longer saw the brand as trustworthy (Aaker).

Do customers trust companies with their data?

Many do not. In a 2023 Pew survey of 5,101 U.S. adults, 81% of those who had heard of AI said companies will use the data they collect in ways people are not comfortable with (Pew Research Center, 2023). Programs that state plainly what they collect and why give members a reason to share more.

Can a loyalty program change its rules after members earn points?

Often, yes. Marriott Bonvoy’s terms say the program can amend its rules, with or without notice. That includes how awards are earned and redeemed, even when a change affects the value of points (Marriott Bonvoy terms). Members’ trust in a program rests on how it uses that right.