Relationship marketing asks a company to earn the next purchase as well as this one. The idea is more than 40 years old. The research on what makes it work is clearer than most guides let on. Loyalty programs are its most common tool, and the place it most often goes wrong.
What is relationship marketing?
Relationship marketing builds ties with customers so they keep coming back. The goal is the tenth sale as much as the first. It runs on trust, service and being known, as much as on price.
In 1994, Robert Morgan and Shelby Hunt gave it a formal shape. They defined it as “establishing, developing, and maintaining successful relational exchanges” (Journal of Marketing, 1994). They saw it as a big shift in how marketing works. The aim moves from the single sale to the long run.
The phrase is younger than the practice. Leonard Berry gave a paper called “Relationship Marketing” in 1983, at a conference of the American Marketing Association. He later wrote that it was the first time the phrase showed up in the field’s literature (Berry, 2002). The paper was reprinted in full in 2002.
Christian Grönroos took the case further in 1994. He wrote that the four Ps of the marketing mix had become a straitjacket. In his view they bred toolbox thinking (Management Decision, 1994). He saw a marketing built on forming and running customer ties as the way forward.
How is relationship marketing different from transactional marketing?
Transactional marketing aims at the next sale. It works through price, promotion and reach. It counts success in units sold. Each sale stands alone, so the customer is a stranger at every purchase.
Relationship marketing aims at the customer’s whole future with the brand. It works through service, recognition and trust. It counts success in how long customers stay and how much of their spend they bring. Grönroos framed the two as ends of a scale (Grönroos). Where a firm sits on it changes how it sets prices and runs quality, and how it trains its own staff.
Most firms run both. A grocer still needs weekly deals, and it can tie them to a member account. The question is which logic leads. Where buyers come back often and service costs are high, the relationship logic should usually lead.
Why does relationship marketing work?
Morgan and Hunt argued that it works through two things, commitment and trust. They tested that model with data from car tire dealers (Morgan and Hunt). It held up against a rival model that left both out.
The best evidence comes from a 2006 review of past studies. Robert Palmatier and three co-authors pooled the research on the topic (Journal of Marketing, 2006). They found good support for its effect on results. Several of their findings change how a firm should spend on it.
| Finding (Palmatier et al., 2006) | What it means for a loyalty team |
|---|---|
| Relationship investment has a large, direct effect on seller performance | Spend on members shows up in results, so track it as an investment by tier |
| Relationship quality drives objective performance most | Measure the strength of the tie as a whole, beyond points earned |
| Commitment drives objective performance least | Stated loyalty in a survey is a weak guide to future spend |
| It works best where the tie matters most to customers | Services and business buyers repay the effort more than low-stakes purchases |
| Ties to a person work better than ties to a firm | A named contact for top members carries more weight than a brand email |
Other studies point the same way. Peter Verhoef studied a firm’s customers over time. Those with a strong emotional bond to the firm stayed longer and gave it more of their spend (Journal of Marketing, 2003). So did members of loyalty programs that paid out economic rewards. Both effects were rather small.
Where does relationship marketing go wrong?
In 1998, Susan Fournier, Susan Dobscha and David Glen Mick warned that the practice was “troubled in practice” (HBR, 1998). Their charge was blunt. The very things marketers did to build ties were often the things that broke them.
They named the pattern. Firms flood people with too many requests for one-on-one ties. They also ask customers for friendship, loyalty and respect without giving the same back. A loyalty program that sends daily offers and hides its earn rules does both.
The second trap is assuming every tie pays. Werner Reinartz and V. Kumar studied more than 16,000 customers at four firms. They found little or no proof that steady customers are always cheaper to serve or less price sensitive (HBR, 2002). Spend on relationships needs the same margin test as any other spend.
How do you measure relationship marketing?
Start with behavior. Track how long members stay, how often they buy and what share of their category spend comes to you. Read each by tier and by the year members joined. Those numbers show whether the tie is getting stronger.
Then add a survey of how members feel, and read it next to what they do. The 2006 review is a warning here. It found commitment, the stated kind of loyalty, was the weakest driver of hard results. A member who says they are loyal is a weaker signal than a member who keeps coming back.
Last, test the costly parts. Give a random share of top members a named contact and hold the rest back for a year. Compare stays, spend and tenure. Without that test, a program cannot tell a strong tie from a customer who would have stayed anyway.
How do loyalty programs build relationships?
Points are the financial part of the bond, and any rival can copy them. Recognition, service and ties to real people are harder to copy. The best programs layer those on top of the points. They save the most personal ones for the members who are worth the cost.
Marriott Bonvoy shows the top of that ladder in its own terms. Ambassador Elite takes 100 or more qualifying nights and at least $23,000 in yearly qualifying spend. Members at that level get Ambassador Service, and the terms refer to each member’s personal Ambassador (Marriott). A member who also meets the bar for the Plus One benefit can gift the status to a partner.
That design fits the 2006 review. The program puts a named person between the brand and its most valuable guests, which is where ties work best.
For illustration, a hotel program has 2,000 top-tier members. Each spends $30,000 a year at a 30% margin. Five service staff at $120,000 each give every member a named contact, for a cost of $600,000. If that lifts tier retention from 85% to 89%, the program keeps 80 more members. Their spend is $2.4 million, worth $720,000 in margin. So the service pays for itself in its first year.
Our guides to brand loyalty and tier strategy show how status and recognition fit into the rest of the program.
How GRAVTY handles relationship marketing
A relationship needs one memory of the customer. GRAVTY’s Member 360 pulls each member’s behavior and purchases into one view, with the household in it. Household pooling and an affiliation graph map the people around the member (GRAVTY for financial services). So a family or a firm can be read as one tie.
The same member view serves every touchpoint. On GRAVTY, the app, the website, the store, the contact center and partner tills read from one real-time member graph. So the agent on the phone sees the same member the app sees.
Frequently asked questions
Who coined the term relationship marketing?
Leonard Berry coined it in 1983, in a paper he gave at a conference of the American Marketing Association. He later wrote that it was the first time the phrase showed up in the field’s literature (Berry, 2002). The paper was reprinted in full in a journal in 2002.
What are examples of relationship marketing?
Loyalty programs, account managers, member events and good service recovery are all forms of it. So is a top tier with a named contact, such as Marriott Bonvoy’s personal Ambassador. Each gives the customer a reason to come back that has little to do with price.
Is relationship marketing the same as CRM?
No, CRM is the software and data behind the work. Relationship marketing is the plan to build long-term ties. A firm can buy CRM software and still run one-off sales campaigns through it.
What is the commitment-trust theory?
The theory says customer ties last when customers feel both commitment and trust toward the firm. Robert Morgan and Shelby Hunt set it out in 1994. They tested it with data from car tire dealers (Morgan and Hunt, 1994). A later review found commitment was the weakest driver of hard results.
Does relationship marketing work for business buyers?
Yes, and the evidence says it works even better there. The 2006 review found these efforts paid off more when the tie mattered more to the buyer, as in business markets (Palmatier et al., 2006). Ties to one person also beat ties to a selling firm.
