Every review, photo and post a customer publishes about a brand is content the brand did not write. It can sell for the brand, and it can also hurt it. Who made it, who owns it and who paid for it decide how a loyalty program can use it.
What is user-generated content?
User-generated content, or UGC, is material that people create and publish on their own. A brand or a hired creator did not make it. Examples include a product review and a photo that tags the brand. The OECD’s 2007 study proposed a three-part test. The content is made public online. It shows a “certain amount of creative effort.” And it is “created outside of professional routines and practices” (OECD).
The same study found that most of this content is made without any hope of profit. Two motives lead its list. People post to connect with peers, and they post to gain fame or prestige. Self-expression is a third (OECD). That matters to a loyalty team, because status and recognition speak to those motives and points alone do not.
Users also decide what works. The OECD notes that the choice of which content succeeds falls to users themselves, through recommending and rating (OECD). A brand can invite content, but it cannot pick the winners.
What are the types of user-generated content?
Five forms cover most of what a program sees. Each needs its own rule for reuse and its own measure.
| Type | Example | What the brand does | What a loyalty team measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reviews and ratings | A product review on a retailer’s site | Shows them where shoppers decide | Review count and rating by tier |
| Photos and video | A customer’s photo with a product | Asks permission, credits the creator, then reuses | Submissions per 1,000 active members |
| Social posts and mentions | A post that tags the brand | Asks before reposting and discloses any reward | Reach of members who post |
| Community answers | A tip in a brand forum | Moderates and recognizes helpful answers | Questions answered per member |
| Contest or challenge entries | A photo sent to a campaign | Sets the usage rights in the entry rules | Entries and new members per campaign |
The OECD’s own table of types starts with text and photos. It then moves on to audio, video and citizen journalism (OECD). That list is older than most social platforms, so the five forms above are the ones a loyalty team meets now.
Does user-generated content change what people buy?
Peer-reviewed work says it does. Chevalier and Mayzlin compared books on Amazon.com and Barnesandnoble.com in 2006. Reviews were overwhelmingly positive at both sites. Even so, an improvement in a book’s reviews led to an increase in its relative sales at that site. For most samples, one-star reviews moved sales more than five-star reviews did. Review length suggested that customers read the text instead of relying only on summary scores (Chevalier and Mayzlin, 2006).
Reviews can also be faked, and that cuts trust. A 2016 study of Yelp found that roughly 16% of restaurant reviews were filtered as suspicious. A restaurant was more likely to commit review fraud when its reputation was weak, with few reviews or recent bad ones (Luca and Zervas, 2016).
Both studies are about reviews. Photos, video and social posts have thinner peer-reviewed evidence on sales. A program should treat their effect as a question to test, and the holdout described below is the test.
What do the rules say about rewarding and reusing it?
Ownership comes first. Under U.S. law, copyright exists from the moment a work is created, and registration is voluntary (U.S. Copyright Office). A customer’s photo is theirs. A brand that wants to repost it asks first and credits the creator.
Rewards come next. In August 2024 the FTC announced a final rule on fake reviews. Its chair said they pollute the marketplace and take business from honest rivals (FTC, 2024). The rule’s text bars incentives given in exchange for reviews “expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative” (16 CFR 465.4). A program can reward the act of reviewing, at any rating. It cannot pay for a good score.
The FTC’s Endorsement Guides add a disclosure duty. Free or discounted products count as material connections, even if the advertiser does not require an endorsement in return. One example covers a program that gives points each time a member posts about a brand’s products. The guide says the points should be clearly disclosed. The advertiser should also take steps to make sure that happens (16 CFR 255.5).
Two more parts of the rule touch loyalty teams. An officer or manager who writes a review of the business must disclose that tie (16 CFR 465.5). And a review page cannot imply that it shows most or all reviews when low ratings are being hidden. Filters are fine if they apply equally to every review, whatever the sentiment (16 CFR 465.7). None of this is legal advice.
How do loyalty programs use user-generated content?
Yelp runs the plainest example. Its Elite Squad asks reviewers for “thoughtful reviews and awesome photos” and gives them an Elite badge. Yelp calls the badge “a mark of trust” and adds perks, such as events. Each month, top contributors get a badge too. Joining takes a profile with a real name and a recent photo. Members then share reviews and photos, and they can nominate themselves or others. The reward is status and access. That fits what the OECD found drives people to post. Our entries on community loyalty and advocacy loyalty cover the wider pattern.
A program can set up the same loop with five rules:
- Reward the act of reviewing at any rating.
- Put the disclosure of the reward next to the content.
- Write the usage rights into the terms of every challenge.
- Tie each piece of content to a member ID.
- Keep a random holdout group, so the lift is measured.
Before a challenge opens, put the rules in writing. Say who can enter and what rights the entrant grants. Say how entries are moderated and what the reward is. Members then know the terms, and the brand knows what it can reuse.
Then track three numbers. Count submissions per 1,000 active members. Compare repeat purchase for contributors with the holdout. Watch the share of entries that pass moderation.
For illustration, a program with 50,000 members offers 100 points for a photo review. If 2,000 members submit one, the program awards 200,000 points. At an assumed cost of one cent per point, that costs $2,000. Each photo costs $1. The team then compares repeat purchase for the 2,000 against a holdout of similar members. Our guide to brand loyalty covers what builds the attachment behind those purchases.
How GRAVTY handles user-generated content
A review helps a program only when it sits on a member record. GRAVTY Member 360 pulls behaviors, influences and transactions into one view. On lji.io, writing a review is one way a customer engages.
Business teams set rewards, recognition and redemption for any segment in GRAVTY Visual Rules, with no code. The rules change as the program does.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between user-generated content and influencer content?
UGC comes from the creator’s own initiative, and influencer content comes from a deal with the brand. The OECD says UGC is created “outside of professional routines and practices” (OECD). Paid or rewarded posts fall under the FTC’s rules on material connections (16 CFR 255.5).
Do you need permission to use user-generated content?
Yes. Copyright exists from the moment a work is created and fixed, so the creator holds it unless they transfer or license it (U.S. Copyright Office). Ask first, credit the creator and keep the permission on file. This is general information and not legal advice.
Can a loyalty program give points for reviews?
Yes, if the points are for writing the review and not for what it says. The FTC’s rule bars incentives conditioned on a particular sentiment, positive or negative (16 CFR 465.4). The Endorsement Guides also call for clear disclosure of a points-for-posts reward (16 CFR 255.5).
Why do people create user-generated content?
Most do it without any hope of profit. The OECD lists connecting with peers, gaining fame or prestige and self-expression as motives (OECD). That is why a badge or an invitation often suits a program better than a points payout.
How common are fake reviews?
In one study, roughly 16% of Yelp restaurant reviews were filtered as suspicious (Luca and Zervas, 2016). The FTC’s 2024 rule bans fake reviews and review buying with a set sentiment. It also lets the agency seek civil penalties against knowing violators (FTC, 2024).
