A traveler books a fare. The next screen shows a higher fare that adds bags, a seat and more points on the same trip. If she takes it, that is an upsell. For a loyalty program, the higher fare also moves her up a ladder of earning.

What is upselling?

Upselling is moving a customer to a bigger or better version of what they are already buying. Zapier calls it upgrading the customer to a better version of the product or service. Its plain case is the fast food habit of making small fries large (Zapier). It differs from cross-selling, which adds a related item and widens the basket.

The table lists the common forms and what a loyalty team can track in each.

FormExampleWhat changesWhat a loyalty team measures
Size or quantitySmall to largeUnits per orderPrice per order line
Premium versionStandard to pro modelPrice of the itemShare of sales at the top version
Bundle levelBasic fare to a fare with bagsIncluded benefitsMix across fare levels
Paid membershipFree tier to a paid tierAnnual fee and benefitsUpgrade rate and renewal
Longer commitmentMonth to yearContract lengthAnnual plan share

How is upselling different from cross-selling?

The two move the sale in different directions. Upselling raises the price of one line in the basket. Cross-selling adds another line. Programs measure upselling by price per item and mix, and they measure cross-selling by basket size and attach rate. Our entry on average order value covers the shared metric.

The two often meet in one offer. A fare bundle that includes bags is an upsell on the fare and a cross-sell of the bags, sold as one package. Test them as two moves anyway, so you can tell which one the shopper values. Test the order too: some shoppers respond to the upgrade first, and others to the add-on first.

How does upselling work?

People judge an option by what sits beside it. Simonson and Tversky named two effects. Tradeoff contrast says an option looks better or worse depending on the tradeoffs in the set. Extremeness aversion says an option gains appeal when it is the middle choice and loses appeal when it is an extreme (Simonson and Tversky, 1992). A three-level ladder therefore tends to lift the middle level.

Huber, Payne and Puto added another. A dominated alternative is worse than one option in the set but not worse than another. Adding one can raise the chance that people choose the option that dominates it (Huber, Payne and Puto, 1982). These are lab findings about choice. They show how a ladder can steer. They do not promise a lift for any one offer.

Design the ladder so each step adds a clear gain. Name the benefit in the member’s terms. Show the price and the difference side by side. Put the level you want most in the middle, and keep the top level real, since a fake top level is a trick.

How do loyalty programs use upselling?

Paid tiers are the clearest upsell. Costco lets paid members upgrade to Executive membership for an extra annual fee of $65 in the U.S. Executive members earn a 2% reward on qualified purchases, generally up to $1,250 a year. They made up about 73.6% of worldwide net sales in 2025 (Costco 10-K). Target runs a free Target Circle membership and a paid tier, Target Circle 360, with unlimited same-day delivery (Target 10-K). Walmart+ adds free shipping on eligible items, delivery from store, fuel discounts and Scan and Go (Walmart 10-K).

Loyalty Juggernaut’s guide calls the common design a hybrid. A free base program is open to everyone, and a paid premium tier sits on top for the members worth the most (Paid loyalty programs). The free base builds reach and data, and the paid tier concentrates spend.

Fare bundles are an upsell with a loyalty hook. Southwest Airlines sells four fares. Basic fares earn two Rapid Rewards points per dollar on the base fare, Choice earn six, Choice Preferred earn 10 and Choice Extra earn 14. Choice Extra fares include perks such as two free checked bags. From January 27, 2026, Southwest moved to an assigned seating model (Southwest 10-K). The higher the fare level, the faster the points. That ties the upgrade to the loyalty currency.

For illustration, a base fare of $200 earns 400 points at Basic, 1,200 at Choice, 2,000 at Choice Preferred and 2,800 at Choice Extra. A member who moves up one level adds 800 points on that trip. The program can price those points and compare them with the fare difference.

How do you measure an upsell, and where does it go wrong?

Track four numbers: the upgrade rate, the price and mix of what sells, the margin, and the regret rate, such as returns, downgrades and cancels. Compare them against a holdout that did not see the upgrade prompt. A paid tier also needs a renewal rate. Our entries on paid loyalty and tiers cover the structure.

Costco’s numbers show the break-even logic. At a 2% reward, the $65 extra fee is repaid at $3,250 of qualified spend, since $65 is 2% of $3,250. A program can use the same math to tell members the spend at which an upgrade pays. It can send the prompt to members who are near that point.

Upsells fail when they feel like a trap. The FTC’s 2022 staff report on dark patterns includes requiring people to listen to a sales pitch or upsell while trying to cancel (FTC staff report, 2022). A member who wants to leave should be able to leave. An upgrade prompt should be a choice with a visible price and a visible no.

For illustration, a program sends an upgrade prompt to 20,000 members who are near the break-even spend. A total of 6% upgrade, which is 1,200 members, and at a $65 fee that is $78,000. A holdout of similar members who got no prompt upgrades at 4%. The prompt added two points, or 400 upgrades, worth $26,000 in fees. The result of the prompt is that lift. The $78,000 includes members who would have upgraded anyway. Check renewal at month 12 before you call the tier a success. A fee earned once is not a fee kept.

Timing matters too. Do not send an upgrade prompt right after a failed redemption or a support complaint. Send it after a good moment, such as a reward earned or a trip completed.

A program can also let members pay for an upgrade with points. That uses the program’s own currency for the upsell and gives points a use that raises revenue. Our entries on cash plus points and pay with points cover the mix of cash and points.

How GRAVTY handles upselling

Loyalty Juggernaut says GRAVTY treats a paid program as configuration. Paid tiers, their perks and the earning rules are written in GRAVTY Visual Rules, a patented rules language. The loyalty team deploys them without an IT ticket (Paid loyalty programs).

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between upselling and cross-selling?

Upselling upgrades the item the customer is buying. Cross-selling adds a related item. Zapier calls upselling a move to a better version (Zapier). Programs measure upselling by price per item. They measure cross-selling by basket size.

What are examples of upselling?

Small fries to large, a standard fare to a bundle with bags, and a free membership to a paid one are common cases. Southwest sells four fare levels, and the points per dollar rise from two at Basic to 14 at Choice Extra (Southwest 10-K). Costco offers an Executive upgrade for an additional $65 a year in the U.S. (Costco 10-K).

Why does a three-tier price ladder work?

People tend to favor the middle option in a set. Simonson and Tversky call this extremeness aversion. An option gains appeal when it sits in the middle and loses appeal when it is an extreme (Simonson and Tversky, 1992). It is a lab finding, so test your own ladder against a holdout.

Is upselling the same as a membership upgrade?

A membership upgrade is one form of upselling. Target’s paid Target Circle 360 tier gives unlimited same-day delivery on top of the free Target Circle membership (Target 10-K). The upgrade has a fee and benefits, so it needs a renewal rate as well as an upgrade rate.

Can upselling be a dark pattern?

Yes, when it blocks a choice the customer is trying to make. The FTC’s 2022 staff report lists requiring people to listen to a sales pitch or upsell while trying to cancel as a dark pattern (FTC staff report, 2022). Let members cancel without a pitch, and show prices before they commit.