A membership program is a program that customers join to get benefits for as long as they stay members. Some are free and pay out for purchases. Others charge a fee, so members pay for access first. The difference sets the economics, the design and the legal duties.

What is a membership program?

A membership program gives people access to benefits. Joining can be free or paid. Researchers Walsman and Dixon split loyalty programs in two. Free rewards programs let customers earn benefits through repeat visits. Paid programs charge a fee for access.

Marriott Bonvoy shows the free kind. Its rules say that membership is free (Marriott). Costco shows the paid kind. Its annual fee is $65 in the US for Gold Star and Business memberships (Costco 10-K).

What are the types of membership programs?

Four types cover most programs. The table gives each with an example from the operator’s own terms or filing.

TypeHow people joinExample
Free rewardsSign up, then earn on purchasesMarriott Bonvoy: membership is free
Annual-fee clubPay once a yearCostco $65 in the US; BJ’s Club $60; Sam’s Club $50
Higher paid tierPay more for a richer tierCostco Executive, $65 more, with a 2% reward up to $1,250 a year; BJ’s Club+ $120, with 2% cash back up to $500; Sam’s Club Plus $110
Subscription bundlePay for a bundle of servicesAmazon Prime: fast, free shipping, video, live sports and other benefits; Walmart+

Each paid type sets a price and then gives the member a reason to renew. Free programs skip the price and rely on earn and burn.

Amazon describes Prime as a membership program. It includes fast, free shipping on tens of millions of items, access to award-winning movies and series, live sports and other benefits (Amazon 10-K). That is a bundle, so one fee buys many services.

Household cards shape the count. Costco counts 64.2 million household cards on top of its 81.0 million paid members (Costco 10-K). Sam’s Club includes a spouse or household card at no added cost (Walmart 10-K). Costco’s Gold Star memberships are for individuals. Business memberships are for businesses.

How do membership programs make money?

Fees can carry the profit. Costco’s membership fee revenue was $5,323 million in fiscal 2025, and its operating income was $10,383 million. Fees were about half of operating income (Costco 10-K).

BJ’s Wholesale reports $499.8 million of membership fee income in fiscal 2025, up 9.5%. It has over 8 million members paying annual fees (BJ’s 10-K). Walmart reports $4.4 billion of membership fee revenue in fiscal 2026, across Sam’s Club, Walmart+ and its other offerings (Walmart 10-K).

Fee increases add to the total. BJ’s raised its Club fee to $60 from $55 and its Club+ fee to $120 from $110, effective January 1, 2025. It says fee income rose because of member gains, retention, higher-tier mix and the fee increase. Costco names new sign-ups and fee increases as the drivers of its 10% rise.

Amazon reports $49.6 billion of subscription services net sales in 2025, up from $44.4 billion in 2024 (Amazon 10-K). That line covers Prime fees and other subscriptions, so it is not a Prime-only figure.

How do you measure a membership program?

Start with the count of paid members. Costco reported 81.0 million at the end of 2025, up from 76.2 million, and 38.7 million of them were Executive. The count includes memberships that expired and did not renew in the prior 12 months.

Then read the renewal rate with its definition. Costco and BJ’s both use a trailing calculation. It captures renewals seven to eighteen months before the reporting date. Costco also leaves out memberships that expire in the last six months of the period. Firms that define the rate differently cannot be compared. Costco’s was 92.3% in the US and Canada and 89.8% worldwide at the end of 2025. BJ’s tenured renewal rate was 90%.

Track higher-tier penetration. BJ’s cites higher-tier growth as a driver of fee income. Sam’s Club cites growth in the membership base and Plus penetration. Each upgrade adds fee income and a richer reward to fund.

Finance teams book the fee over time. Walmart books it over the term of the membership, which is generally one year. Amazon books subscription revenue over the subscription period.

Last, test the program. Hold back a random group from a new benefit and compare renewal and spend. A fee program with no holdout cannot tell its effect from its pre-existing fans.

How do you design a membership program?

Start with the value case. BJ’s makes it in its filing. It says it believes members can save over ten times their $60 fee when they spend $2,500 or more a year on manufacturer-branded groceries.

Members work to earn the fee back. In restaurant data, Walsman and Dixon found that paid enrollment brings a need to self-justify and to find the easiest path to payoff. They also caution that piling on benefits can fail to improve service, loyalty or satisfaction.

BJ’s Club+ pairs 2% cash back with a 5-cent per gallon fuel discount and two free same-day deliveries. Fuel and delivery give members more ways to earn the fee back.

Sam’s Club ties the two models together. Members can earn Sam’s Cash rewards and use them to pay membership fees.

For illustration, a $60 fee with a 2% reward needs $3,000 of spend before rewards alone repay it. A member who spends $1,500 earns $30 and is $30 short. Other benefits, such as fuel savings or free delivery, have to cover the gap. The program owner can track the share of members who have earned back the fee.

In September 2025, the FTC announced a settlement with Amazon over Prime. It said Amazon signed up millions of people without consent. It also said Amazon made canceling hard. Amazon will pay a $1 billion civil penalty. It will also give $1.5 billion in refunds (FTC).

The order lists changes to the sign-up and exit flows. They make a useful checklist for any paid program. This is not legal advice, so check it with your own counsel. The FTC cited the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, and the refunds cover an estimated 35 million people.

  • Decline button. Show a clear button to decline the membership.
  • Plain terms. Disclose the cost, the date and frequency of charges, whether the plan auto-renews and how to cancel.
  • Easy exit. Let members cancel the same way they signed up. The process cannot be difficult, costly or time-consuming.

How GRAVTY handles membership programs

GRAVTY’s base platform supports three kinds of membership. They are family, corporate and subscription. Tier fees and renewal rules are rule logic. GRAVTY’s patented Visual Rules let non-technical users write earn, burn, tier and bonus logic. They simulate it. Then they deploy it without an IT ticket (financial services).

Riyadh Air built Sfeer, its lifestyle membership, on GRAVTY before it flew. The program reached 1 million members less than a year after launch (Loyalty Juggernaut clients). GRAVTY also pools households through its affiliation graph.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a membership program and a loyalty program?

A membership program grants access to benefits, often for a fee, while a loyalty program rewards purchases. The two overlap. Sam’s Club charges a fee and also pays Sam’s Cash rewards, which members can use to pay the fee.

How long does a membership last?

Many paid memberships last one year. Walmart says its membership terms are generally one year, though some offerings are month to month (Walmart 10-K). BJ’s says its membership is generally 12 months (BJ’s 10-K).

What is a good renewal rate for a membership program?

Costco and BJ’s report rates near 90% or higher. Costco’s was 92.3% in the US and Canada at the end of 2025 (Costco 10-K). BJ’s tenured renewal rate was 90% (BJ’s 10-K). Compare rates only when firms define them the same way.

Can members earn rewards on a paid membership?

Yes, higher paid tiers often add a reward. Costco Executive members earn 2% on qualified purchases, up to $1,250 a year (Costco 10-K). BJ’s Club+ members earn 2% cash back, up to $500 a year (BJ’s 10-K).

Does canceling a membership have to be as easy as joining?

In the FTC’s order with Amazon, yes. The order requires an easy way to cancel Prime, using the same method consumers used to sign up (FTC). Treat it as a guide for any paid program and ask your counsel about your own market.